Benefits and Challenges of Virtual Exchange Between Pre-Service Teachers: Spanish and Turkish Context

Authors

Nazlı Ceren Cirit-Işıklıgil
Ana Chapman
Tuncer Can

Synopsis

Although a valuable tool in language teacher education, transnational virtual exchange (TMVE) among pre-service teachers (PSTs) from diverse linguistic and cultural backgrounds remains understudied, and no prior work has paired Spanish and Turkish participants. Grounded in Byram’s (1997) intercultural communicative competence (ICC) model and Guth and Rubin’s (2015) Collaborative Online International Learning (COIL) framework—which informed both task design (credit-bearing activities embedded in each institution's coursework) and interpretation of intercultural gains—this study examines the benefits, challenges, and suggestions reported by 25 PSTs of English in a five-week Zoom-based TMVE. Following O’Dowd’s (2020) TMVE model, PSTs worked in teams on instructor-directed tasks to design ELT materials, using English as a lingua franca. Data came from pre-, mid-, and post-surveys and focus group interviews and was analyzed via the constant comparative method (qualitative responses) and frequency analysis (closed-ended items). Findings revealed benefits across three domains: language learning, intercultural learning, and professional development (including informal tutoring and coordination roles). PSTs reported increased oral fluency and confidence, particularly from communicating in English with non-native peers facing similar struggles. Intercultural exchanges prompted questioning of stereotypes and recognition of shared experiences, while collaborative tasks strengthened conflict-resolution and organizational skills. Notably, both cohorts reported comparable benefit categories but differing emphases: Turkish PSTs foregrounded professional development, while Spanish PSTs emphasized language gains. Challenges centered on scheduling conflicts, insufficient task guidance, uneven group commitment, and technical limitations. Suggestions included instructor-coordinated schedules, a joint orientation session, regular office hours, and extending the exchange duration. With empirical data from an underexamined multilingual TMVE context, this study extends TMVE beyond the predominantly U.S.-Spain and bilingual pairings to date. Findings offer practical guidance—clearer task guidance and communication channels, longer exchange periods—for structuring future VEs, with implications for integrating VE into teacher education curricula for global citizenship education and post-pandemic teacher preparation.

Downloads

Forthcoming

December 30, 2026

How to Cite

Cirit-Işıklıgil, N. C., Chapman, A., & Can, T. (2026). Benefits and Challenges of Virtual Exchange Between Pre-Service Teachers: Spanish and Turkish Context. In W. B. James, C. Cobanoglu, & M. Cavusoglu (Eds.), Proceedings of the Global Conference on Education and Research: Volume 6. Domain Press. https://books.domainpress.org/index.php/spbup/catalog/book/53/chapter/295